Wednesday, May 26, 2021

Canadian Jewish Community Forum Preliminary Statement of Purpose

 


STATEMENT OF PURPOSE


               A preliminary Statement of Purpose for Consideration and Determination        

1. To promote participation in, engagement with, and a sense of ownership of the Jewish agenda in Canada by all members of the Canadian Jewish community by the establishment of active democratic local grassroots community advocacy groups across the country.

2. To provide a forum to educate, discuss and debate issues of interest and concern, both regional and national that impact Canada, the Canadian Jewish community and the welfare of the people of Israel.

3. To engage with other faith, Indigenous, racial, ethnic and cultural communities to find common cause in matters pertaining to the promotion of civil discourse, reconciliation, inclusivity and mutual understanding and to fight against antisemitism, discrimination, racism and hatred in all their forms. Many important issues facing society at large are  viewed to be relevant to the Jewish community. If we are to have a voice in the society we are creating together, we must discuss and address issues as they emerge together as Canadians.

4. To engage the former leadership of Canadian Jewish Congress and new young leaders to honour, learn and draw from the legacy of the Canadian Jewish Congress, that worked and fought for social justice in Canada with the purpose of making Canada a peaceful, inclusive and just society for all of its peoples.




CJCF Backgrounder




THE BEGINNINGS 

In 1919, at voting stations located in synagogues, schools and organizational offices, over 25,000 Jews from across Canada democratically elected the delegates to the first convention of Canadian Jewish Congress to be held in March of that year at the Monument National Theatre in Montreal. 

During that time, there were a number of Jewish organizations already in Canada, several originating in Europe. Among the existing entities, some represented a diversity of political, religious and philosophical viewpoints while others were communal mutual assistance societies, cultural and literary organizations, labour groups and the like. It was these organizations, on behalf of their constituents and members, that at that time clearly perceived the need for cooperation, not competition, and the benefits of one united community voice for Canadian Jewry to coordinate and advocate for its communal needs, issues of importance to the community and its participation in Canadian society. Thus, they came together to create the Canadian Jewish Congress. The choice of the name was consciously determined. It was to be clearly identified as the central Jewish body, with the descriptive adjective to ensure its Canadian perspective, and a congress, meaning a forum of representatives or delegates assembling to discuss and address matters of common concern.

PARLIAMENT OF CANADIAN JEWRY

Canadian Jewish Congress was to become the Parliament of Canadian Jewry serving as the community’s democratic and grassroots voice, advocate and intervenor with governments, courts and other communities, domestically and internationally. Over the years, it was the forum where all issues of concern to Jews in Canada were discussed and debated, and appropriate action was determined while maintaining unity and consensus. It welcomed and benefited from the representation and active participation of Jews from every city, town and village where Jews resided across the length and breadth of Canada. It was the recognized address for the Canadian Jewish community for Jews globally.

As the Parliament of Canadian Jewry it developed a unique structure involving regular and frequent meetings of elected representatives from across Canada to the National Officers and the larger National Executive governing bodies. Every three years, National Plenary Assemblies of nationally elected delegates took place in different cities for the election of National Officers, for organizational business and for debate and adoption of policy resolutions. In addition, regional bodies across Canada existed with democratically elected representatives and leadership, providing input to the discussions with respect to national and international issues in addition to addressing uniquely local issues.

ISSUES AND ADVOCACY

In 1919, the critical issues facing the community included the oppression of Jews worldwide, the need to assist in the resettlement of Jewish refugees and immigrants to Canada, the conditions for Jewish workers and the dream to establish a Jewish homeland in Israel. Over the following decades, Canadian Jewish Congress provided activism and strong advocacy with respect to all the vital issues facing the Jewish community in Canada as well as global concerns facing the broader Canadian society. It was devoted to strengthening the safety, status, welfare and vibrancy of Jews in Canada, Israel and other Jewish communities worldwide. It fought against discrimination and the scourges of antisemitism and racism; alerted the world to the need to outlaw dangerous hate propaganda; advocated for the prosecution of Nazi war criminals; defended human and civil rights and social justice; fought for the freedom of Soviet Jewry; championed inclusiveness and dialogue among all groups and segments of society, spoke out on behalf of oppressed people; and participated in the processes of Canadian Constitutional reform and the development of the Charter of Rights. Very significant and effective components of its advocacy efforts were the strategic, well reasoned and respected interventions, submissions and participation, led by some of the most learned and respected legal experts in the country, in many of the most important judicial proceedings and commissions that formulated and developed the body of law of Canada that defined the guiding principles, values and ideals of Canadian society.

It is due to its history of being an activist and structured forum of democratically elected representatives of the Jewish grassroots, individuals and organizations from all regions of Canada and its involvement in so many important issues national and international that Canadian Jewish Congress was held in esteem and respect by governments across party lines, the media, other ethnic and religious entities and the public which commonly sought its views, insights and assistance. Its contributions for the benefit of society were widely appreciated and acknowledged.

This experience, record, history and credibility of Canadian Jewish Congress are relevant to contemporary community concerns and may be utilized to deal with the current disturbing and difficult issues during these days when so many are feeling alienated, discriminated against and sensing an absence of effective participation and influence in the development of decisions affecting their lives and matters important to them. Even as an initial step, the availability of a forum for discussion of issues of concern in a congenial, constructive and positive atmosphere would be beneficial in addressing the current issues.

THE CHALLENGES 

We are living in an exceptionally challenging and, in many ways, dangerous period of history globally. We have witnessed the terrorist attacks in Paris in 2015 at Charlie Hebdo and Hyper Cacher kosher supermarket, claiming the lives of 17, including four Jews, and also at the Stade de France and other locations later in the same year, claiming the lives of 130 victims. In London, England in 2017, a terrorist attack resulted in 6 deaths and 49 injured near the Palace of Westminster and in the same year 11 died and 48 were injured in a further attack in the London Bridge and Borough Market area. Closer to home, we have witnessed attacks at the Tree of Life Synagogue in Pittsburgh, killing eleven and wounding six and at the Chabad of Poway in San Diego, resulting in one death and three injured. Nor, have we been immune here in Canada when in 2017, at the Islamic Cultural Centre of Quebec City, six people were massacred and five others seriously injured. Most recently, eight people, including six women of Asian descent, were fatally shot in spas in Atlanta.

Shockingly, we have seen the Capitol in Washington and, before then, the Parliament Buildings in Ottawa, the homes and symbols of free democracy in leading countries in the world, invaded and attacked. These assaults on our fundamental institutions represented attacks upon our society and way of life of liberty, safety and peace. It is urgent that the words and actions of neo-nationalists, misogynists, bigots, racists and fascists end and that governments are pressed to act clearly and decisively, using all available laws and other tools of democracies. As well, the racism, misogyny and bias that exist within our institutions, businesses, military and law enforcement agencies must be effectively addressed.

We are also witnessing the rise of intolerance and hatred toward those who may hold different political views. Freedom of political expression that does not promote hatred is a value that brought previous generations and new immigrants fleeing oppression to Canada. This value must be promoted and protected. It is incumbent upon our political leaders to create harmony and unity and not exploit differences of opinion to create divisions and hostility. As well, to encourage civility and meaningful cooperation, it is incumbent upon us as a Jewish community to reach out and enter into meaningful dialogue with other religious, ethnic, racial, national and community groups and, importantly, Indigenous peoples, as we had so actively done in past years.

Our input and participation, as a community, in other important national and societal matters such as the environment, health care, discrimination based upon gender, intolerance with respect to sexual orientation, immigration, poverty, housing, mental health, opioid abuse, education, research and innovation and the economy, just to identify several, would be useful today. As times change and society evolves, so is there a need, as a community, to be forward looking and to address new issues as they arise with contemporary reasoning and insight.

The safety and welfare of Israel are central and hold a place of supreme importance to us as a Jewish people. It is our responsibility, as a community, to ensure that the best qualities, the talents and contributions made by Israeli society are made known and receive the appropriate recognition and acknowledgement. It is incumbent upon us, through the mechanisms available to us to ensure that the good relationships between Canada and Israel are maintained and enhanced and to support the efforts of the parties in the Middle East to achieve a sustainable and equitable peace so that they may all live in safety, security and prosperity. It is also important that we communicate with the people and government of Israel with respect to our common interests from the Canadian perspective.

THE TASK

There is much that requires attention, effort and work. We have the skilled, experienced and wise people interested in helping and we have the history and credibility.  We need to attract many others from the vast  pool of talent and knowledge that exists in our community and act with democratic unity and harmony.

Our goal is to take lessons from the past and use them to inform communal policy in the present and future, to promote Jewish values of chesed, diversity, anti-racism and embrace harmony within a Canadian context and in the spirit of the former Canadian Jewish Congress by addressing the current urgent issues that our own  community and our society are facing and witnessing here in Canada and globally ie antisemitism, discrimination and racism, breakdown of civil discourse, victimization of groups based upon differences in religious, cultural or political views, the sense of disillusionment, discontent and alienation which are being exploited to create hatred and divisions, as well as the environment and other important and timely issues. There is a need for clear and real political leadership combining experience with new ideas. As has also been said, we need to apply the history and experience of Canadian Jewish Congress to inform us as we address current issues and reach out to all ages and genders, LGBTQ, Jews of colour, those with divergent political views, the previously involved and the newly interested.

***

Welcome to the newly established Canadian Jewish Community Forum, composed of coast to coast leadership from the former Canadian Jewish Congress and new young leadership who seek to benefit our community and Canada. Please join us in this important work.

Follow our blog at: https://cjc1919.blogspot.com.

 




 


Former CJC leaders spearhead the formation of the Canadian Jewish Community Forum


A group of former Canadian Jewish Congress senior leaders from coast to coast, as well as some new young leadership,  have come together to establish the Canadian Jewish Community Forum (CJCF).

Les Scheininger
For 92 years, until its dissolution in 2011, CJC was  recognized as  the Parliament of Canadian Jewry and served as the community’s democratic and grassroots voice, advocate and intervenor with governments, courts and other communities, domestically and internationally. Over the years, it was “the forum” where all issues of concern to Jews in Canada were discussed and debated, and appropriate action was determined while maintaining unity and consensus.

In its statement of purpose, it is emphasized that the CJCF will  provide a forum to educate, discuss and debate issues of interest and concern, both regional and national, that impact Canada, the Canadian Jewish community and the welfare of the people of Israel.

A national steering committee was established in January, as well as a larger advisory body, and meetings have been taking place virtually.

Renee Switzer
The group hopes to engage the former leadership of CJC and new young leaders to honour, learn and draw from the legacy of Congress, a body that worked and fought for social justice in Canada. The CJC understood that making Canada a peaceful, inclusive and just society is good for all of its peoples.

It is the prime objective of the CJCF to take lessons from the past and use them to inform communal policy in the present and future, to promote Jewish values of chesed, diversity, anti-racism and embrace harmony within a Canadian context. In  the spirit of the former CJC it wishes to create a forum for the greater Jewish community to provide input and determine what the current urgent issues are that our own community and society are facing and witnessing here in Canada and globally.

The CJCF is now a federally incorporated all-volunteer organization. 

Bernie Farber

Like CJC, the CJCF believes its strength will be in regional representation. Regional bodies are now being established. More details will follow on the new organization’s rollout.

Members of the steering committee are  Les Scheininger, Toronto (former national president); Bernie Farber, Toronto (former CEO);  Renee Switzer, Vancouver  (former National Executive Chair); Dr. Michael Elterman, Vancouver (former Pacific Region Chair);Dorothy Zalcman Howard (former National Executive Chair); Frank Schlesinger, Montreal (former National Legal Counsel);  Mike Cohen, Montreal  (former National Director of Communications); Israel Ludwig, Winnipeg (former Manitoba Chair);  Len Dolgoy, Edmonton (former Alberta Chair); Hal Joffe, Calgary (former National Community Relations Chair);  Jon Goldberg, Halifax (former Atlantic Jewish Council Executive Director); Ivan Levine, Fredericton (former Atlantic Jewish Council President); and  young leaders  Henry Paikin and Jimmy Gutman of Ottawa, both of whom were very active in campus life. A Saskatchewan rep will be named soon.

Dorothy Zalcman Howard

A website (cjcf.ca/fcjc.ca)  is in development. For now you can go to https://cjc1919.blogspot.com  for more details and email thecjcf@gmail.com.



Friday, March 5, 2021

Former CJC leaders continue to meet among great enthusiasm

Former Canadian Jewish Congress leaders  from coast to coast met via Zoom on March 3 and expressed great enthusiasm that the legacy of the organization established in 1919 is not forgotten and perhaps even revived.

Some of the participants on the most recent Zoom call.

From articles  authored by former CJC Executive Vice-President and  General Counsel Jack Silverstone and National Director of Communications Mike Cohen and published in the Jewish Standard Magazine and The Suburban Newspaper, a definite desire to bring back the CJC brand was created. The response was well beyond what  could have  been imagined. Joining us for the second call were some leading recent university graduates who expressed great interest in a CJC revival.  We had so many CJC alumni eager to be part of the second call,  we had to establish a waiting list.

Initially the consensus is to focus our attention on organizing a series of lectures related to themes from CJC’s decorated past. These can be organized virtually and we hope to roll some news out to that effect soon. CJC was an organization that truly had a voice in every corner of the country and we strongly believe that this is needed again.

CJC ceased to exist 11 years ago. The prevailing view, simplified but with legitimate resonance, seems to be that CJC was a grassroots, community based, consultative organization as distinct from others today which are top down.

" I believe   that the loss of CJC  has resulted in alienation,  loss of direction and purpose, and in my community  a loss of youth involvement," said lawyer Len Dolgoy of Edmonton. "CJC  inspired  and was brilliantly led by lay people and staff."

This ad hoc committee would like to bring back the Alan Rose Fund Human Rights Lectures. Funds were collected for this purpose by the CJC 25 years ago, but they seem to have disappeared into a black hole. Alan Rose was a senior CJC executive for decades.

Eric Vernon recalled  CJC's social justice and human rights record, which  created a contemporary agenda that   captured the attention of both younger and older demographics,  both within and outside of  our community. By combining safe space for a wide range of views, inter-community dialogue and an agenda that reflects the day's priority issues we created a niche that was   historically-respectful and currently relevant.

Stay tuned folks!

 






Thursday, February 11, 2021

Former CJC leaders from coast to coast reconvene for discussions

 Just over 10 years after the Canadian Jewish Congress was dissolved, former leadership   from across the country convened via an enthusiastic Zoom call to discuss how the legacy of the once prestigious organization could be maintained.

The so-called “Parliament of Canadian Jewry” had a unique structure that provided for Canada-wide representation. Delegates from national, regional and local Jewish organizations as well as synagogues and service clubs from across the country were able to have meaningful input into national and regional policy through regular local meetings, regional conferences and annual consultations culminating in a plenary assembly every three years.

Some of the former CJC leadership on the screen.

Taking part of the call were:  Jack Silverstone, Ottawa (former National Executive Vice-President and General Counsel); Bernie Farber, Toronto (former Chief Executive Officer); Les Scheininger, Toronto (former National President);  Eric Vernon, Ottawa (former Director of  Government Relations);  Michael Crelinsten, Montreal (former Quebec Region Executive Director); Dorothy Zalcman Howard, Montreal (former Quebec Region Chair); Mike Cohen, Montreal (former National Director of Communications);  Michael Elterman and Renee Switzer, Vancouver (former Pacific Region Chairs); Joseph J. Wilder, Winnipeg (former National Community Relations Committee Chair); Jon Goldberg, Halifax (former Atlantic Jewish Council Executive Director); and Hal Joffe, Calgary (former National Community Relations Chair).

The main consensus from this call was to find a way to share the many achievements of CJC during its 90 years of existence:  combatting anti-Semitism; steering the Nazi war criminals dossier; Israel advocacy; the Soviet/Syrian/Ethiopian Jewry advocacy efforts; the coalition of Jewish, Italian and Greek communities which advocated for Canadian unity; and standing up for other minority communities. It is hoped that initially a lecture series can be launched to both remind the community of these milestones while informing the next generation who may be too young to know about the CJC mandate.

Since this call, a number of others have stepped forward to be added to the list of those seeking to get involved. 

Stay tuned to this blog.


2015 article in the CJN called for the return of Canadian Jewish Congress

By Zach Paikin and James Gutman - November 20, 2015 

In the recent federal election, we witnessed the continuation of a trend that has been apparent within Canada’s Jewish community for the past several years: division between the left and the right.

Division isn’t a bad thing when it is accompanied by meaningful and respectful dialogue. The problem today is that our community is in the midst of a dialogue of the deaf. There is very little overlap between the policy priorities, general worldviews and public pronouncements of the Canadian Jewish left and right.

Members of the Canadian Jewish Congress met on the stage of "His Majesty's Theatre" on Guy Street in Montreal on June 20, 1946. The Israeli flag and a flag with the Canadian Coat of Arms are suspended from the ceiling. WIKI COMMONS PHOT
Our community is in need of a political institution that can unite Jewish Canadians from across the spectrum. Instead of polarization and cacophony, we need a vehicle that truly reflects our community’s diversity. That is why we are calling for the re-establishment of an elected Canadian Jewish Congress.


For most of its history, the CJC was a truly democratic and representative organization. Just like Canada itself, the organization was a parliamentary democracy formed of several regional components. Each region was allocated a certain number of representatives based on the size of their local Jewish population.

Every three years, elections would be held, in which every member of the Jewish community – above the age of 18 and in good standing with their local United Jewish Appeal – would vote for their representatives on the CJC executive. The executive was, in effect, the Canadian Jewish community’s parliament.

In its heyday, the executive boasted nearly 160 individuals. On a triennial cycle, it would meet in a plenary session to vote for the CJC’s officers, which included a president, a chair and sitting representative officers of each region. This smaller group of officers ran the day-to-day affairs of the CJC, while ultimately remaining accountable to the executive.

Later on in its history, after the CJC was incorporated into the umbrella organization that wouldeventually become known as the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA), its democratic component largely faded away. This was an unfortunate development, as it gave grounds for many to criticize the organization as being too focused on progressive causes and not enough on Israel- and Jewish-specific issues.

Similarly, many progressive and centrist Jews believe today that their community’s leading advocacy organizations are too Israel-centric and thus unrepresentative of the political diversity of Canadian Jewry. This is why the re-establishment of an elected, democratic CJC is so important. We need to build a Jewish community in which all feel welcome.

If we fail to bring our community’s present-day polarization to an end, there could be significant long-term consequences. Growing numbers of Jewish Canadians will feel increasingly alienated from their community’s leadership and institutions, an alienation they may pass on to the next generation. Some may end up feeling the divide so strongly that they will fail to give their children a Jewish education.

In much of the Diaspora,preserving and nourishing Jewish identity is one of our community’s paramount and most difficult challenges. Community is one of the bedrocks of Jewish life. We cannot let our personal ideological preferences get in the way of building a Canadian Jewish community that will remain strong, welcoming and forward-looking over the long term.

Do not misunderstand our position: the work that CIJA does on Israel-related and other issues is professional, important and needs to continue. The connection between Canadian Jewry and Israel is strong, and we need an organization that will help to ensure that the Canada-Israel friendship remains a durable one.

But ultimately, for the sake of the long-term health of the Canadian Jewish community, we need to establish an advocacy organization that is democratic, multi-faceted and representative of our community’s many voices and passions. Our community can band together to tackle domestic and international issues, in accordance with both spiritual and secular values. Our love for Israel and our devotion to other causes need not be mutually exclusive.

The choice with which our community is presented is clear. If both left-leaning and right-leaning Jewish Canadians continue to place ideology over unity, then public perception of our community will worsen, and the pillars that support it will weaken. We need to recognize and embrace our community’s diversity of opinion, and channel that diversity into something rich and positive with the help of a truly representative institution.

We need to bring back an elected, democratic Canadian Jewish Congress. 


Zach Paikin is a columnist for The Hill Times. James Gutman is a Jewish educator and community organizer.



The legacy of Canadian Jewish Congress: Former leaders discuss in Suburban Newspaper Video Presentation

Following the publication of an opinion piece  on  The Suburban website (see below)  about the Canadian Jewish Congress, there has been a lot of talk generated about possibly reviving the brand. We speak to former National Executive Vice-President and General Counsel Jack Silverstone, former President Les Scheininger and former National Executive Committee Chairs Dorothy Zalcman Howard and Renee Switzer.

You can see the video here . 



Globe and Mail Editorial on current political turmoil in Israel praises the former CJC

    OPINION The unspeakable silence of the Canadian Jewish establishment ANDREW COHEN SPECIAL TO THE GLOBE AND MAIL PUBLISHED YESTER...